April Book Club: Mid-Month Check In

8 min read

Deviation Actions

isthisthingstillon's avatar
Published:
4.1K Views


Has everyone been keeping up with the reading list for CRLiterature Book Club: April 2015 - and how do we feel about Christian and Ana so far? Aren't they just, like, the bestest?





I kid. And I apologize for posting the mid-month a few days late; but, hey, the book's got a lot of poems and we're reading to past the midpoint anyway, so it fits! This month, in case you're just checking in for the first time now, we're reading April Book Club: Selected Poems of Anne Sexton, a pivotal work of 20th-Century confessional and feminist poetry. And right now, if you're up-to-date, you should have read up to at least the end of the poems taken from Love Poems. Let's discuss!

Question the First



In your estimation, have the poems so far portrayed medicine, especially gynecology/obstetrics and psychiatry, in a flattering light or more of a horrifying one? And do you think the stylistic treatments Sexton has given the two fields (and the disparate themes and images she links to the two in her works) are colored solely by her personal experiences, or more as a reflection and challenge of social perceptions about femininity and its connection to mental illness?



Question the Second



People often compare Sexton's treatment of psychiatry in poetry to that of Plath; if you're familiar with Plath's work, do you see the similarity? I personally don't, apart from their being women who wrote about medicine in the same era; I'm more likely to compare Sexton to Susanna Kaysen than Plath, outlook-wise.

Question the Third



Does Sexton seem happy in her roles as woman, wife and mother so far? Do some roles seem to satisfy her more than others? Does she want to be a wife and mother, or is she working too hard to convince herself and her readers?



Question the Fourth



So far there haven't been many poems that have been interconnected, no "plot arcs", in the collection. But the poems are divided by the collections in which they were originally published. Do the "themes" of each collection seem clean-cut to you or is it all blending into a cohesive body of work so far?

The Rest of the Book



Know how I kept saying "so far"? It's because the collection derails now, into longer interconnected works and "genre" pieces, with no confessionalism for a bit. The back half of the book has all of my personal favourite works by Sexton (except one I'll share at month-end), but it's going to read like a completely different poet save for the New England Gothic voice that carries through. Keep going, though, because we have prizes!



We'll be giving away a three-month premium membership and copies of You Might Curse Before You Bless by Allie Marini Batts (courtesy of ELJ Publications) and The Uncertainty Principle by Roxanna Bennett (courtesy of Tightrope Books) to participants. (You don't want an ocelot; they pee on everything you love.)

We are reconvening on May 1st to wrap up the month, so discuss, then get back to reading!

Skin by Dan Leveille
Comments12
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
vespera's avatar
1.
Horrifying. Ah, so delightful. I think a lot of this is personal experience and then her over-dramatization. Because she was queen of this.

2.
I personally don't see a comparison other than same school of poetry (confessionalism) and some of the same subject matter (suicide). I think they get roped together so much because they were contemporaries, but if you put down a new Plath and a new Sexton poem in front of me, something never published by either of them, but written in the later half of their career (mostly a comment on Plath here as her early work is so fucking horrible and derivative I could tell it was hers only because it certainly wasn't Sexton) I could tell who was who. There are a lot of poets who I wouldn't be able to tell the difference between...

3.
I think Sexton wanted to be a wife and mother, but didn't know what to do with it once she got it. So there's a lot of conflict in her work for me. As for being a woman, I get the feeling she enjoys it, every messy last bit, as it gives something for her and her work to crawl over.

4.
Clean-cut! No, cohesive! No idea. I really wish I had a good handle on what was in this collection and how it was arranged, lol, cause it could go either way. Her individual books are all so terribly cohesive.

The Rest of the Book
I'm just going to assume that the first section has all my favorite bits in it because that's how it's like in the full collection? I'm not sure. Anywho, I like her earlier work better, and some bits at the very end, but her middle work dwadles.